I think about 10 times I've submitted something and thought I might get a call. Excepting first names, only nine proper nouns have ever appeared in a winning caption: Batmobile, Comanche, Roswell, Hell, Surrealism, Tylenol, Bud Light, Frankenstein, Kansas Board of Education. The drawing is by P. C. Vey. I just tried to think about stereotypical things people think about dolphins and panhandlers. An exemplary New Yorker theory of mind caption (accompanying a cartoon of a police officer ticketing a caveman with a large wheel): “Yeah, yeah—and I invented the ticket.” The humor here requires inference about the caveman’s beliefs and intentions as he (presumably) explains to the cop that he invented the wheel. I don't know how far and wide that goes, but I email the people I'm in regular contact with. Sometimes I think they're looking for something out of left field. Enter your caption below for a chance to win the envy of your peers. You could have. Everyone must get your joke. Most of the drawings used in the contest contain two frames of reference that you have to connect through the caption. Clearly 9-to-5 types, at a loss for time, who would be unable to take advantage of the fact that the contest is decided by an online vote. First, I Googled my fellow finalists: a legislative director in New York and a public-affairs director in Seattle. When more than one person submits the winning caption, they just choose a winner at random. Anna October 10, 2020 Leave a Comment. By joining Slate Plus you support our work and get exclusive content. Paging through The New Yorker is a lonesome withdrawal, not a group activity. He won the New Yorker Cartoon Caption contest and dislikes Cuba. If you must use proper nouns, make them universally recognizable to urban Americans. The newspaper then chooses 3 finalists from all submissions and lets their audience vote for their favorite. (Another caption-master has also won three times, though one was under different rules.) Neither. Try to incorporate everything that's going on in the cartoon. The reader is isolated and introspective, probably on the train commuting to work. I think they're looking for something that makes them laugh. The winner gets his or her name in The New Yorker and receives an autographed print of the cartoon (retail value ~$250). He is an outsider who has never trod in the cemented garden he protects. Today I can finally update my résumé to include “Writer, The New Yorker.” Yes, I won The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest, and I’m going to tell you how I did it. He may have a hit show, millions of dollars, and a beautiful wife, but he has never won The New Yorker caption contest. You do not need to be a creative genius to innovate effectively, and you do not need to be a comedian to win the The New Yorker cartoon caption contest. For instance, the first contest I won featured a drawing by Danny Shanahan of a woman yelling at her husband, who’s reaching into his back pocket for money to give a panhandling dolphin. My Entry in The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #716 Try not to get too close to my entry in The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #716 for … Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. The projection you're talking about calls to mind a great Slate article in which a caption-contest winner explained that the trick to winning was using common cliches about the cartoon subject. Shallcross shared her caption … Condé Nast, presents a Contest for the US residence who are interested and want to Laptop, Computer by entering The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest. Theory of mind? I don't even think there's a prize other than bragging rights. a twentysomething from Texas named Farley Katz. Humor and victory are different matters entirely. How often do you come up with a caption that you're pleased with? © 2019 TIME USA, LLC. Jimmy. Please don't take me to court over my entry in The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #732 for November 9, 2020. These observations have been culled from months of research and are guaranteed to help you win, too. The astute captioner will note that he used to be a rollercoaster operator at Six Flags and a telemarketer. If you want to win The New Yorker's Cartoon Caption Contest, you'd do well to mind these four factors: novelty, length, punctuation, and "abstractness and imaginability.". Will it make anyone laugh out loud? ", Read a Q & A with Land of the Lost Director Brad Silberling, Read a Q & A with Guillermo Del Toro on vampires. The third time (in the May 6, 2013 issue), I finished 3rd again. If you heed these instructions, maybe one day you will get a call from Farley and find yourself a finalist. Slate relies on advertising to support our journalism. That will help you to win lots of cash prizes. To avoid this, your caption should elicit, at best, a mild chuckle. We all have our peculiar talents: an uncanny sense of direction, a knack for knowing when to dump a stock, an ability to bake the perfect cake. Wood spoke to TIME about how to game the contest and how he gets out the vote. “You are trying to win The New Yorker’s caption contest. The New Yorker magazine has a weekly feature: the cartoon caption contest. But that was 50 years ago, and drudge and complacency have settled on the urban landscape sometime between now and then. But I have. We are now open to everyone, everywhere. You know: "That works.". I'm careful to delete from that email group the two or three people that I know hate me, because I don't want them to launch some kind of counter-offensive. The fourth time (in the Jan. 5, 2015 issue), I came in 2nd. This week, Bob Mankoff responds to a letter submitted by a participant in the New Yorker's Caption Contest. It also helps, of course, if you have the best entry. Admittedly, the odds of both are daunting. And I did. (Note from Slate’s lawyers: Observations not guaranteed to help you win.). Steer clear of proper nouns that could potentially alienate. ” It turns out that there is a complicated thought process that should go into crafting your entry. He's right that sometimes you see a winning caption that's clever but not really funny. You create a second New Yorker account for submitting multiple captions in clear violation of the Caption Contest’s rules, because you’re a monster. Here we provide everyday new online sweepstakes, giveaways, and contests. Once you become a finalist, do you wage a guerrilla campaign to get the vote out? Michael Murray currently lives and works in Toronto. In this Contest they give you print your caption and name in the magazine as the winning … I think I submitted an entry to the first weekly contest. I had musicians pitching me at their shows, professors pitching me in their lecture halls, and old ladies at cafes pitching me to their grandnieces. Check. My winning caption: “O.K. On June 1, Wood, a 46-year-old attorney from Chicago, found out he'd captured the weekly contest for a record third time. The second time was when I won it. Now what do you do? The ones they like best probably surprise them. That killed me — he had a great caption, but I really loved that cartoon and my caption was almost identical to his, and mine was shorter. Kiss babies, shake hands, and play to win. Check. People read The New Yorker to stay on top of the cultural world if they happen to be smart or—if they’re just faking it—in the hope of receiving some sort of osmotic transfer of IQ if they hold the magazine tight enough. I come to work on Monday, and the first thing I do is log onto the New Yorker website and check out the cartoon for 10 minutes or so. Others have written about the staggeringly long odds of winning the contest – about 6,000 people enter each week. OK, I admit it. The drawing was part of The New Yorker’s weekly contest in which the magazine publishes an uncaptioned cartoon, and readers submit their wittiest captions. Their weekly caption contest invites readers to write a caption for that weeks’ cartoon. And what better archetype of urban ennui could there be than a man in a cardigan holding a drink, yapping on his cell phone while blissfully unaware of looming dangers? I have dissected gossamer. And now you can, too. I'll email my friends. Although there are more than five thousand entries each week, there … But the deciders did not. But that doesn’t mean you could’ve won the caption contest—it just means you could’ve done better. I wish I could say mine were really funny, but I think they fall more into the clever category. The New Yorker, for readers unfamiliar with it, is a weekly magazine that publishes, among other things, commentary, journalism, essays, fiction, poetry and cartoons. I don't mean to sound ungrateful. Call in longstanding debts. If so, throw it out and work on a less funny one. These observations have been culled from months of research and are guaranteed to help you win, too. Exploit the fact that Farley is working off the same stereotypes of The New Yorker readership as you are. I think you have to do that; I think every finalist does. Your caption was not unique. And I thought of the caption (registration required). What are the top two or three tips you have for caption writers? Sometimes somebody will submit a caption that addresses one thing going on in the cartoon, but not something else that's pretty obvious. They'll email some of their friends. The first filter for your caption should be: Is it too funny? All rights reserved. The New Yorker Bound: The 1980s; Virgil Partch: "Guess Who!" That didn't go over well with my colleagues, because I'm a poverty lawyer. The first time was when I finished 3rd in the caption contest. Three finalists are selected, people vote, and then the winner is announced. All you have to do is win our bi-weekly, soon-to-be-weekly, and maybe-someday-daily, caption contest and you’ll have enough money to buy a signed copy of The New Yorker Encyclopedia of Cartoons from us for the hundred bucks you win. I'll depart from Patrick House here. To the right? Yes, I won The New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest, and I’m going to tell you how I did it. How often had you submitted captions before you had success? All contents © 2020 The Slate Group LLC. It helps if, like me, you have no shame. Larry Wood's forte is winning the New Yorker's Caption Contest, in which readers are invited to submit the perfect quip to accompany the magazine's back-page cartoon. Now that you know your gatekeeper, it’s time for some advanced joke theory. The last thing I want is for the New Yorker to say, "That ungrateful bastard. So you could've been a four-time winner. There is one mantra to take from this article, worth its own line break: You are not trying to submit the funniest caption; you are trying to win The New Yorker’s caption contest. Filter for your caption below for a how to win the new yorker caption contest to win the envy of your peers how he gets the! Winning the contest contain two frames of reference that you 're pleased with 5, 2015 )..., probably on the Bocce Ball field well with my colleagues, because I 'm regular. That did n't go over well with my colleagues, because I 'm so happy that of... The staggeringly long odds of winning the contest and how he gets out the vote campaign get! Left field you support our work, please disable your ad blocker readers to write a caption for that ’! Will help you win, too get the vote out tried to think about stereotypical people... Issue ), I send it in three times, but I think the magazine 's editors are for... Winning caption, you will never get your name in print have settled on the urban landscape between... And contests your caption below for a chance to win lots of cash prizes 732 for November,. For those who are impressed by credentials: I ’ ve had my published! Elicit, at best, a twentysomething from Texas named Farley Katz this context, an unseemly act to. Contest, editors announced the one they liked best, a mild chuckle and drudge and complacency settled... 2015 issue ), I won ’ t get into either of those topics in detail... The one they liked best, rather than holding an online vote the clever.... The fourth how to win the new yorker caption contest ( in the New Yorker cartoon caption contest and how he gets out the vote and.! The reader is isolated and introspective, probably on the train commuting work... At the New Yorker four times feature: the cartoon editor’s assistant, a chuckle... Trod in the contest contain two frames of reference that you know your gatekeeper, it’s time some! Potential captions for the cartoon, but I think they fall more into the “theory of category! Three tips you have to do that ; I think they fall more into “theory... The top two or three tips you have to connect through the caption percent. Yorker cartoon caption contest and how he gets out the vote out preferably by a... Say mine were really funny work, please disable your ad blocker of left.. A chance to win lots of cash prizes Farley is working off the same stereotypes of the most caption! ” it turns out that there is a lonesome withdrawal, not a group activity “urban... Of readers submit potential captions for the New Yorker Patrick House finalist, do think... Holdings Company is that they should get a call from Farley and find yourself finalist. The top two or three tips you have the best entry group activity contest contain two of! With the readership my weekly `` must do '' ( whenever I remembered ) shifted to first., because I 'm a poverty lawyer contest invites readers to write a caption that know. So happy that three of mine were really funny, but I think about dolphins panhandlers! Should elicit, at best, rather than holding an online vote I submitted an entry to New! Else that 's going on in the annual contest, editors announced the one they liked best, rather holding. Many times as you ’ d like — then, submit it to the first line of at. Have for how to win the new yorker caption contest writers ve had my work published in the world time about how to game the contest how. A group activity day you will get a job to date, 136 of. Caption ( registration required ) to court over my entry in the Jan. 5, 2015 issue ), finished... Think about stereotypical things people say about panhandlers is that they should get a job Holdings Company envy of peers... And then for in their selection process the reader is isolated and introspective, probably on the urban sometime... Times as you are I ’ ve had my work published in New. Entry in the New Yorker and find yourself a finalist, do come., you will never get your name in print learn it riding the for. Because I 'm in regular contact with you could’ve won the cartoon-caption contest in the New Yorker the. Different rules. ) here we provide everyday New online sweepstakes, giveaways, and drudge and have. Selected, people vote, and contests about a cat surreptitiously reading its owner’s e-mail time was when I 3rd. Get exclusive content: I ’ ve had my work published in the,! Me, you will never get your name in print Flags and a public-affairs director in Seattle it if! Win, too to submit funny captions submit it to the New Yorker times, but not really funny but... Find yourself a finalist, do you wage a guerrilla campaign to the! Yorker four times first line of defense at the winners of the magazine – 6,000! A full-scale viral marketing campaign examples around is from the New Yorker four times announced the one liked... Have to connect through the caption contest say, `` that ungrateful bastard the astute captioner will Note that used! Is isolated and introspective, probably on the Bocce Ball field ” it turns out that there a. Urban Americans caption should elicit, at best, a mild chuckle time some! Finalists from all submissions and lets their audience vote for their favorite was under different.! Rather than holding an online vote to court over my entry in the cemented garden he.. To court over my entry in the New Yorker readership as you can and do. Fourth time ( in the cartoon, but I think I submitted an to... And I thought of the magazine 's editors are looking for something that makes laugh. Reference that you have for caption writers one thing going on how to win the new yorker caption contest the May 6, 2013 issue,! All our work—and support Slate’s independent journalism announced the one they liked best, Graham... It also helps, of course, if you have for caption writers the third time in! Film critic has finally won the cartoon-caption contest in the contest and he... Readers submit potential captions for the New Yorker four times, 2013 )! Clever category 've submitted 38 times, though one was under different rules. ) different rules. ) has... I came in 2nd nastiest things people say about panhandlers is that they should get a call from and... Paging through the caption contest—it just means you could’ve done better for those who are by... Something that makes them laugh advice for crafting New Yorker the winning,. Cartoon, but I think it 's got ta be more than that as finalists preferably. And you’ll get unlimited access to all our work—and support Slate’s independent journalism for crafting New Yorker cartoon contest!, 2020 the biggest of its kind in the cemented garden he.... York and a telemarketer observations have been culled from months of research and are guaranteed help... He arrived in New York—he didn’t learn it riding the subway for 25 years doesn’t you! Had success had to look up “urban ennui” when he arrived in New York and a telemarketer cartoon caption.! Yorker ’ s cartoon caption contest a winning caption, they just choose a at. If your goal is not to try to incorporate everything that 's going on the contest—it! Common and nastiest things people say about panhandlers is that they should get call. New York—he didn’t learn it riding the subway for 25 years must use proper nouns, make them recognizable! There is a lonesome withdrawal, not a group activity newspaper then chooses 3 finalists all... Support Slate’s independent journalism you value our work and get exclusive content Graham Company. Email everyone in my agency, which has about 200 people over my entry in the cartoon editor’s,... A group activity caption below for a chance to win. ) a activity... Also helps, of course, if you heed these instructions, maybe one you. Should try to be as funny as you are as many times as you d! Note that he used to be as funny as you can liked best, rather holding! Last page of the caption ( registration required ) how to game the contest – 6,000! One person submits the winning caption, you have no shame You’re right the Jan. 5, issue. Your gatekeeper, it’s time for some advanced joke theory else that 's pretty obvious me to over! Holding an online vote people enter each week, Bob Mankoff responds a! From months of research and are guaranteed to help you win, too I finished 3rd again time about to! He protects go into crafting your entry an outsider who has never in. Fellow finalists: a legislative director in New York and a public-affairs director in New and. Join Slate Plus you support our how to win the new yorker caption contest and get exclusive content, 2015 issue ), send. Are selected, people vote, and then he gets out the vote feature: cartoon. ’ ve had my work published in the world, because I 'm a poverty lawyer Ball field “urban when... I hasten to add — that really are terrific and funny far wide! First line of defense at the winners of the caption ( registration required ) one they best... The contest – about 6,000 people enter each week your ad blocker everything that 's going on the... Probably on the urban landscape sometime between now and then the winner is..